This article was from the site http://www.climateaudit.org/ on January 13th.
______________________________________________________
Gore Scientific “Adviser” says that he has no “responsibility” for AIT errors
By Steve McIntyre
In earlier posts, we observed that Al Gore’s An Inconvenient Truth claimed that “Dr Thompson’s thermometer” confirmed Michael Mann’s hockey stick, but, when analysed, what Gore described as “Dr Thompson’s thermometer” merely proved to be Michael Mann’s hockey stick mis-identified. No wonder it resembled Mann’s hockey stick - or, to use the phrase more common in climate science, no wonder there was a “remarkable” resemblance.
Recently we’ve seen Pierrehumbert’s hysterics over at RC about Courtillot’s misidentification of a solar series. I’m sure that all of you recall similar hysterics from Pierrehumbert calling Al Gore out on this error. You don’t?
Hu McCulloch of Ohio State University now writes about a recent encounter with Lonnie Thompson, the serial ice core non-archiver:
On January 11, Lonnie Thompson gave a talk on Climate change at Ohio State. After his talk, I asked him if the graph identified by Al Gore as “Dr. Thompson’s Thermometer” in his book and film was really based on his ice core research.
Thompson admitted that an error had been made, and even had a slide ready that showed the data of the Mann Hockey Stick plus Jones instrumental data that Gore’s figure was based on, alongside an average of dO18 z-scores from 6 of his Andean and Himalayan ice cores, similar to the 7-series graph that appeared in his 2006 PNAS article. He stated that he recognized the error right away, and even sent Gore (and Mann, as I recall) an e-mail pointing out the mistake.
When I pressed him if it wouldn’t be appropriate to make a more public announcement, given the high-profile nature of the error, Ellen Mosley-Thompson, his wife and co-author, stood up and offered that it was Gore’s error, not theirs, so that they had no responsibility for it, and that in any event there was no forum in which to make a correction.
I suggested that since OSU’s Byrd Polar Research Center has a website with a News page, it would be trivial and virtually costless to post a press release clarifying the matter for the millions of readers and viewers of Gore’s book and film who are not on Thompson’s e-mail list.
“Gore’s error”. “No responsibility.” “No forum”.
Here’s a picture from the OSU website. Ohio State University press releases have also stated that Thompson was an adviser to Gore for the documentary.
Thompson’s online CV says that he was on the “Science Advisory Board” for Inconvenient Truth prior to its release in April 2006. So he was on the Board but he didn’t bear any responsibility. Sure, Lonnie. Sure, Ellen.
Gore used the term “my friend Lonnie Thompson” and Thompson doesn’t know how to correct the error. Sure, Lonnie.
“No responsibility.” “No forum”. No shame.
Northeast Ohio weather and science blog covering severe storms, long term outlooks, climate, behavioral meteorology, technology and other observations
Monday, January 21, 2008
Thursday, January 17, 2008
The Colonel's Daughter has RSV
Tuesday, January 08, 2008
Cleaning Out the Basement...
I've had this box of old toys and other miscellaneous stuff from my childhood which I've been pressured to go through to eliminate the "clutter" in the corner. Here is what I found:

Knight Rider Stomper 4x4


Knight Rider Stomper 4x4

A Few Atari Catalogs from 1982

The Instruction Booklet from Yars Revenge
Friday, January 04, 2008
Chuck Norris as VP?
Can you see it?
Chuck Norris as VP?
Now that Mike Huckabee won the Iowa caucuses on the republican side, many are wondering, IF Huckabee wins the GOP nomination, would Chuck Norris become the VP running mate? (Maybe not many...well, in fact just me and a few people at work...)
Regardless, I say go for it, Mike!
I'm not endorsing Mike Huckabee in any way, I'm just posing a HUGE WHAT-IF...
I guarantee you this, If Chuck Norris became VP, several things would happen overnight:
* Every US citizen would be required to learn the roundhouse kick
* Flannel would become popular
* Beards would become the norm again
* Instead of the State of the Union Address in January, all of the networks would play Mission in Action and Delta Force back to back.
* Lastly, at the UN, instead of an ambassator, we would put a huge life-size cutout of Chuck Norris in the chair normally occupied by the ambassator. The cutout would look like this:
Chuck Norris as VP?
Now that Mike Huckabee won the Iowa caucuses on the republican side, many are wondering, IF Huckabee wins the GOP nomination, would Chuck Norris become the VP running mate? (Maybe not many...well, in fact just me and a few people at work...)
Regardless, I say go for it, Mike!
I'm not endorsing Mike Huckabee in any way, I'm just posing a HUGE WHAT-IF...
I guarantee you this, If Chuck Norris became VP, several things would happen overnight:
* Every US citizen would be required to learn the roundhouse kick
* Flannel would become popular
* Beards would become the norm again
* Instead of the State of the Union Address in January, all of the networks would play Mission in Action and Delta Force back to back.
* Lastly, at the UN, instead of an ambassator, we would put a huge life-size cutout of Chuck Norris in the chair normally occupied by the ambassator. The cutout would look like this:
Wednesday, January 02, 2008
What Happened to Tom Bosley?

I ask this not to make fun of his age or his appearance but seriously, what happened to him?
The last time I saw him a few years ago, he was doing infomercials for some company. But evidentally, he must have aged 20 years since then because he's not looking so good. We here at Evening With Sabs hope all is right with Mr. Bosley.

Compare him to Rutger Hauer and Tom seems healthy.
Monday, December 31, 2007
Happy New Year!
(Pictured is Times Square with confetti falling)Its hard to believe that 2007 is basically over.
For me, it was filled with many welcome changes. The first and most rewarding was the birth of my daughter, the second was a better work schedule for the family which, aside from the lack of sleep--who doesn't--has been been a godsend. I truely hope that 2008 will be blessed with just as much warmth and fulfillment.
What about 2008. Is this really a special year?
2008 is divisible by 2, 2, 2 and 251.
2008 is a leap year which means that Christmas is on a Thursday which means a four day weekend.
Most high school seniors were born in 1990. Crap. That's scary.
2008 is season 7 of American Idol. Great. More wannabee crooners who quit their jobs at the local greasy spoon.
The 4th Indiana Jones Movie titled and Indian Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull.
Finally, maybe a female president.
Here are a few new search engines that are up and coming in 2008:
http://www.kartoo.com/
http://www.quintura.com/
http://www.goshme.com/login.jsp;jsessionid=B43C41AED84C67E50A5C4D95AD3CA7F9
http://www.zuula.com/
http://www.gigablast.com/
For me, it was filled with many welcome changes. The first and most rewarding was the birth of my daughter, the second was a better work schedule for the family which, aside from the lack of sleep--who doesn't--has been been a godsend. I truely hope that 2008 will be blessed with just as much warmth and fulfillment.
What about 2008. Is this really a special year?
2008 is divisible by 2, 2, 2 and 251.
2008 is a leap year which means that Christmas is on a Thursday which means a four day weekend.
Most high school seniors were born in 1990. Crap. That's scary.
2008 is season 7 of American Idol. Great. More wannabee crooners who quit their jobs at the local greasy spoon.
The 4th Indiana Jones Movie titled and Indian Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull.
Finally, maybe a female president.
Here are a few new search engines that are up and coming in 2008:
http://www.kartoo.com/
http://www.quintura.com/
http://www.goshme.com/login.jsp;jsessionid=B43C41AED84C67E50A5C4D95AD3CA7F9
http://www.zuula.com/
http://www.gigablast.com/
Tuesday, December 25, 2007
Thursday, December 20, 2007
Holiday Wishlist from 1982
We all have a wishlist for the holidays. Maybe an I-POD or some wi-fi device or maybe a plasma tv or clothes or something of that ilk.
Maybe the catalog from your favorite store just doesn't list what you want. If that's the case, then you might want to try this.
A friend of mine found this person's flickr site which shows pages from the 1982 Sears Catalog...

ALL 600+ OF THEM!
Check out the price of this piece of cutting edge technology above.
http://www.flickr.com/photos/wishbook/sets/72157594229749541/

I don't know what's worse. The fact that someone actually spent the time scanning in 600 pages of a 25 year old Sears catalog or that I found it fascinating enough click through it to pick my favorites.
Maybe the catalog from your favorite store just doesn't list what you want. If that's the case, then you might want to try this.
A friend of mine found this person's flickr site which shows pages from the 1982 Sears Catalog...

ALL 600+ OF THEM!
Check out the price of this piece of cutting edge technology above.
http://www.flickr.com/photos/wishbook/sets/72157594229749541/

I don't know what's worse. The fact that someone actually spent the time scanning in 600 pages of a 25 year old Sears catalog or that I found it fascinating enough click through it to pick my favorites.
Monday, December 17, 2007
Evening With Sabs Two Year Anniversary Post

On Saturday, all of us at Evening With Sabs celebrated our second anniversary on World Wide Web.
Never did I expect this website to garner such a following. My ultimate goal is to make some money with the site. As of this writing, our gross income from is endeavor a paltry ZERO.
Wait. I think we got some free potato salad last summer. That counts....sort of.
At last check in our two years of existence, we referenced Barry Bonds, the late Victor French, Ernest Borgnine and John Stamos. Yet, our audit shows no mention of Wilfred Brimley. You can bet your brand-spanking new diabetes testing supply kit that this will soon change in year three.
Happy Birthday!
Monday, December 03, 2007
The Politics of Politics
"Air-fouling, oil-drilling, earth-raping conservative fossil fools."
Or...
"...apocalyptic global-warming-denying homophobes"
Or better yet...
"Hippie, granola, wacko, non-patriotic, anti-Jesus freaks"
Heard some of these classic blasts? I found these on various websites illustrating how our stereotypes, whether factual or not, have interwoven their way into the political arena. And frankly, its now starting to piss me off.
I know this kind of talk has been around since America was founded more than 200 years ago. All you have to do is read about the political divisions that existed in the late 1700s right after the Revolutionary War. The two main political parties back then--the Federalists and the Democratic-Republicans----surely "slung some mud" to prove their point(s). However, in this
passage from Thomas Jefferson, the "smack" isn't quiet what we are used to.
"...to the states as a bulwark against that consolidation, the fear of which produced the whole of
the opposition to the constitution at its birth."
the opposition to the constitution at its birth."
(I sight this passage not for its political message but for the use of the word "bulwark". Wow,
what a word! Any candidate that uses this in a speech gets my vote.)
Back to the task at hand.
In this day-in-age, with more information at our disposal than ever before, its hard not to steer
clear of political stereotypes. Conservatives stereotype liberals as radicals who are anti-establishment, anti-christian, anti--US, anti-war on terror non-conformists who want big business to suffer in any way possible. Liberals stereotype conservatives as old-fashioned, traditional, pro-upper class, super-religious, pro-money, anti-environment, racist, anti-change hardliners.
clear of political stereotypes. Conservatives stereotype liberals as radicals who are anti-establishment, anti-christian, anti--US, anti-war on terror non-conformists who want big business to suffer in any way possible. Liberals stereotype conservatives as old-fashioned, traditional, pro-upper class, super-religious, pro-money, anti-environment, racist, anti-change hardliners.
While some of these descriptors of each group might be true for some, they are not true of all. Its a shame that a year away from the 2008 Presidential Election that these monikers will permeate political talk ad nausium. For the first time, we have a woman running for the highest seat in the land and as of this writing, favored heavily and already, the mudslinging has already begun. The candidates are going right back to the well with the same old cliched rhetoric. Republicans preach that Democrats are not "for the war on terror" because they won't spend the money "to protect" us basically calling they unamerican. They say that the Dems are for more government, against free enterprise and an increase in taxes. The Democrats charge the GOP of being for an increased military, against taxing the rich and not caring about the poor. Blah, blah, blah...
You know what is scary, we've all heard this before and its the same old thing. It shouldn't
surprise any of us that there are people who believe alot of what they hear and are shaped by
these verbal blasts. To put it another way, the general public's opinion is shaped by stereotypes perpetrated by self-serving politicians who are constantly on a soapbox trying to garner ever point in the polls by using the same basic cliched attacks that each candidate used before them and we fall for it every time.
Here's some advice. Maybe the candidates should, ooh I don't know, focus on what they will do for America rather than what so-and-so did or didn't do or won't do. That way we don't have to weed through the endless B.S. to get to the real meat-and-potatoes of how they would handle a specific issue.
Then again, I really wonder how many presidential wannabees really have a plan of attack. These platitudes seem like a clever way to mask the fact that they probably have no plan. The plan is:
Gain popularity, get elected and worry about a plan later. I can guarantee you this: What the candidates say from here on out won't be anything new. The sad part is that most of us will believe it.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

